Originally posted by newbreedbrian
| Quote: | Originally posted by tireironsaint
| Quote: | Originally posted by newbreedbrian
i suppose, but songs like "man boy love", "pantysniffer", and "i like cheese" sound like a joke to me. i highly doubt they're meant as anything else.
i'm sure you get what i mean, and they're definitely funnier than anything by hardskin. i still consider that a slip in otherwise good taste on your
part | Well, yeah, I didn't mean to
imply that the songs aren't funny and/or jokes, I just think there's something else implied when a band is a "joke band". Fer instance, the vast
majority of Darkbuster's songs are funny, but I would never consider them a joke band. On the other hand, the vast majority of Hard Skin's songs
aren't funny in and of themselves, it's the fact that they are putting on an act of being semi stereotypical English Skinheads when they really don't
come from that angle at all that makes the band a joke band to me.
As far as musical taste goes, I would honestly say that if you put aside the whole joke band aspect of them, Hard Skin would have to be one of the top
ten Oi bands to have released anything in the past five years. Maybe that partly has to do with that whole 90's Oi resurgence dying out, as well as
the fact that most current Oi bands sound like that Ten Hole Bootboys thing, but it also has to do with Hard Skin nailing the sound perfectly.
|
yeah i have no doubt there's worse out there. i'm pretty out of touch with whats going on in the oi scene these days, but if ten holes are
representative of the current state of things i don't think i'm missing much really. i'm sure neither of us is gonna change the others mind on this
one, so we'll have to agree to disagree. |