Thorp and Sailor's Grave Board

One singer... Multiple bands.... Who's best?

XHonusWagnerX - 10-31-2005 at 03:25 PM

Heres a list of singers that are in more than one band. Im curious what one band of that singer each person likes best.
Here are the ones I came up with and the bands listed below each singer are in the order I like them best.


CHOKE:
Last Rights
Slapshot
Stars and Stripes
Negative FX

ROB LIND:
Blood for Blood
Ramallah
Sinners and Saints

GLEN DANZIG:
Misfits
Samhain
Danzig

DAVE SMALLEY:
D.Y.S.
Down By Law
ALL
Dag Nasty

IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat
Teen Idols
Fugazi

HENRY ROLLINS:
Black Flag
Rollins Band
S.O.A.

RAY CAPPO:
Shelter
Better Than a Thousand
Youth of Today

MIKE PATTON:
Faith No More
Mr. Bungle
Phantomas
Tomahawk

JELLO BIAFRA:
Dead Kennedys
Lard
w/ Melvins
w/ No Means No
w/ D.O.A.

EZEC:
Skarhead
Crown of Thornz
Ice Pick
Danny Diablo

MAX CAVELARA:
Sepultura
Nailbomb
SoulFly

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Operation Ivy
Transplants
Rancid

Discipline - 10-31-2005 at 04:35 PM

CHOKE: (tie)
Slapshot
Stars and Stripes


ROB LIND: (tie)
Blood for Blood
Ramallah

GLEN DANZIG:
Misfits

DAVE SMALLEY:
D.Y.S.

IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat

HENRY ROLLINS:
Black Flag

RAY CAPPO:
Youth of Today

MIKE PATTON:
Don't like any of his stuff

JELLO BIAFRA:
Dead Kennedys

EZEC:
Crown of Thornz

MAX CAVELARA:
Sepultura

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Rancid

WINTHESKIN - 10-31-2005 at 04:54 PM

tim armstrong wasnt the singer in op ivy

crazyfists28 - 10-31-2005 at 05:06 PM

i think i've got to go with rob only cuz all three bands are so drastically different in tone, content and delivery....

tireironsaint - 10-31-2005 at 06:59 PM

CHOKE:
Last Rights
Slapshot
Stars and Stripes
Negative FX
I love all of these bands and would have to rate them in the order listed here already.

ROB LIND:
No contest, Blood for Blood
followed by
Sinners and Saints
and Ramallah don't even place in the running for me

GLEN DANZIG:
Misfits, definitely
Samhain, second runner up
Danzig, everything after the first album is ridiculous and the first album is pretty fuckin' cheesy too

DAVE SMALLEY:
D.Y.S. If we're talkin' about the Brotherhood album, fuck yes. If it's the follow up metal record....well, let's not go there.
Down By Law one of the only poppy bands(or I guess they're considered "Melodic Hard Core, whatever the fuck that is) I can still listen to
ALL not really
Dag Nasty...Dave was definitely the best singer for Dag Nasty

IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat....of course
Teen Idols....if you mean the Teen Idles, they were good only in light of what they led to.
Fugazi....no thank you.

HENRY ROLLINS:
ruined Black Flag along with Ginn's "experimental" bullshit
Rollins Band are pure shit
S.O.A. would be the only band worth mentioning in regards to Mr. Gap model

RAY CAPPO:
I liked Youth of Today when I was in high school.
Shelter and
Better Than a Thousand
were never worth a shit to me.

MIKE PATTON:
Um, no.

JELLO BIAFRA:
Dead Kennedys


EZEC:
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.
Oh, were you serious?

MAX CAVELARA:
I hate these bands...

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Didn't sing for Operation Ivy and every other band he's been in is fuckin' horrible.

XHonusWagnerX - 10-31-2005 at 08:47 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by tireironsaint
IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat....of course
Teen Idols....if you mean the Teen Idles, they were good only in light of what they led to.
Fugazi....no thank you.

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Didn't sing for Operation Ivy and every other band he's been in is fuckin' horrible.


Stupid type-o on Teen Idles, my bad!

I know Tim didnt sing for OPIV, but he did some vocals so I put them in there.

tireironsaint - 10-31-2005 at 09:14 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by XHonusWagnerX
Quote:
Originally posted by tireironsaint
IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat....of course
Teen Idols....if you mean the Teen Idles, they were good only in light of what they led to.
Fugazi....no thank you.

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Didn't sing for Operation Ivy and every other band he's been in is fuckin' horrible.


Stupid type-o on Teen Idles, my bad!

I know Tim didnt sing for OPIV, but he did some vocals so I put them in there.
Granted Op Ivy was the only decent band he's been in, so I guess you gotta credit him a bit, although I really can't listen to them anymore. Anymore meaning since about 1993 or 94.

XnMeX - 10-31-2005 at 11:09 PM

CHOKE:
Stars and Stripes

ROB LIND:
Blood for Blood

GLEN DANZIG:
Misfits

IAN MCKAYE:
Minor Threat

MIKE PATTON:
Faith No More

Side Note: Mr. Bungle (thier 2nd album sucks cock, others are great)

MAX CAVELARA:
Sepultura

TIM ARMSTRONG:
Rancid